Identification of a lawyer with a client as a violation of the rights and guarantees of lawyer activity

2024;
: 138-143

I. KOMARNYTSKA. Identification of a lawyer with a client as a violation of the rights and guarantees of lawyer activity. Bulletin of Lviv Polytechnic National University. Series: Legal Sciences. 2024. Vol. 11, No. 1(41), pp. 138-143. https://doi.org/10.23939/law2024.41.138

1
Lviv Polytechnic National University, Institute of Jurisprudence and Psychology

The article is devoted to highlighting one of the actual problems of identifying a lawyer with a client. The European direction of the development of Ukraine as a legal state actualizes the problems of guaranteeing the rights and freedoms of the participants in the judicial process, as well as their effective protection against socially dangerous encroachments. A bar exists to provide professional legal assistance in Ukraine. The principles of the organization of advocacy activities and the implementation of advocacy activities in Ukraine are determined by the Law "On Advocacy and Advocacy Activities", decisions of the National Association of Advocates of Ukraine, the rules of advocacy ethics, etc. At the same time, the organization of the high-quality work of the bar and the implementation of the principle of competitive justice requires the mandatory provision of real security guarantees for defenders or representatives of persons. The state has a duty to ensure that lawyers are not identified with their clients or with the motives of their clients' actions as a result of their professional duties. Lawyers can be identified with clients because they are accused of serious crimes, because they receive confidential information, or because they defend their clients. This often happens in high-profile or politically motivated cases, including those involving accusations of treason or terrorism in connection with the armed conflict in eastern Ukraine. Lawyers continue to be identified with their clients and face negative consequences not only at the hands of violent, extremist and radical groups, but also as a result of the abuse of legal procedures against them. Under no circumstances should attorneys identify with their clients or their clients' motives for acting as a result of representing clients, including those whose political beliefs are contrary to the official position of the government.

 

  1. Pro advokaturu ta advokats`ku diyal`nist` : Zakon Ukrayiny` vid 5 ly`pnya 2012 roku # 5076-VI. URL : https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/5076-17 (Accessed: 29.11.2023 [in Ukrainian].
  2. Osnovni polozhennya OON pro rol` advokativ. URL: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/%20995_835#Text (Accessed: 22.12.2023) [in Ukrainian].
  3. Konsty`tuciya Ukrayiny`: Zakon Ukrayiny` vid 28 cherv. 1996 r. #254k/96- VR. [in Ukrainian].
  4. Komitet zaxy`stu prav advokativ ta garantij advokats`koyi diyal`nosti Vseukrayins`koyi gromads`koyi organizaciyi «Asociaciyi advokativ Ukrayiny`». 152 URL: http//www.uaa.org.ua/about /komitety/presa/protection%20of% 20the %20 rights%20of%20lawyers.pdf. (Accessed: 22.12.2023) [in Ukrainian].
  5. Rishennya Nacional`noyi asociaciyi advokativ Ukrayiny` #49 «Pro nedopushhennya ototozhnennya advokativ z kliyentamy` ta vtruchannya v profesijni prava advokativ» vid 05 serpnya 2020 r. URL: https://unba.org.ua/assets/uploads/ legislation/rishennya/2020-08-05-r-shennya-rau-49_5f4637e9c8bd4.pdf. (Accessed: 22.12.2023) [in Ukrainian].
  6. Garantiyi advokats`koyi diyal`nosti v Ukrayini u svitli standartiv Rady` Yevropy`, tekstova translyaciya. Sudovo-yury`dy`chna gazeta. 2020. URL: https:// sud.ua/ru/news/publication/160070-garantiyi-advokatskoyi-diyalnosti-v-ukrayiniu-svitli-standartiv-radi-yevropi-tekstova. (Accessed: 25.12.2023) [in Ukrainian].
  7. Rekomendaciya N R (2000) 2 Komitetu ministriv Rady` Yevropy` derzhavam-chlenam «Shhodo povtornogo rozglyadu abo ponovlennya 170 provadzhennya u pevny`x spravax na nacional`nomu [...] // Rada Yevropy`, Komitet Ministriv Rady` Yevropy`; Rekomendaciyi, Zapy`ska, Mizhnarodny`j dokument vid 19.01.2000 # R(2000)2. [in Ukrainian].
  8. U NAAU vzyaly`sya za problemu ototozhnennya advokativ z kliyentamy` URL:https://zib.com.ua/ua/144253-u_naau_vzyalisya_za_problemu_ototozhne nnya_advokativ_z_klien.html (Accessed: 25.12.2023) [in Ukrainian].
  9. Polozhennya pro komitet zaxy`stu prav advokativ ta garantij advokats`koyi diyal`nosti: rishennya Rady` advokativ Ukrayiny` # 182 vid 27 ly`pnya 2013 r. URL: https://unba.org.ua/assets/uploads/legislations/ rishennya/2013. 07.27-rishennya-182.pdf. (Accessed: 23.12.2023) [in Ukrainian].
  10. Zvit pro porushennya prav advokativ ta garantij advokats`koyi diyal`nosti v Ukrayini. (2021) Nacional`na asociaciya advokativ Ukrayiny`. 2021. S. 44. [in Ukrainian].
  11. NAAU skly`kaye zasidannya komitetiv z pry`vodu porushen` prav advokativ z boku suddiv VAKS URL: https://zib.com.ua/ua/ 143613-naau_ sklikae_zasidannya_komitetiv_z_privodu_porushen _prav_ad.html. (Accessed: 23.12.2023) [in Ukrainian].
  12. Komitety` NAAU dadut` pravovu ocinku kozhnomu vy`padku porushennya prav advokativ. Kvalifikacijno-dy`scy`plinarna komisiya advokatury` Ky`yivs`koyi oblasti. 2020. URL: http://kdkako.com.ua/komitety-naaudotrymuyut%CA%B9sya-pravovykh-vidhukiv.... (Accessed: 20.12.2023) [in Ukrainian].
  13. Pro zvernennya do ukrayins`ky`x ta mizhnarodny`x insty`tucij z py`tan` porushennya prav advokativ u zv'yazku z nevy`konannyam pravooxoronny`my` organamy` sudovy`x rishen` URL:https://unba.org.ua/assets/ uploads/legislation/rishennya/2020-08-05-r-shennya-rau-47_5f4637af1b899 pdf (Accessed: 23.12.2023) [in Ukrainian].