The article is devoted to the analysis of criminal offences against the will, honour and dignity of a person in the context of modern Ukrainian legislation. The author highlights how the legal regulation of these categories has historically transformed, which has a significant impact on the interpretation and application of criminal law in modern conditions.
The author examines the twofold interpretation of the object of criminal offences – both social relations protecting personal freedom, honour and dignity, and the values themselves as such. In particular, the article focuses on the lack of effective protection of honour and dignity through criminal law, which is confirmed by the decriminalisation of libel and insult. The article also discusses the correspondence between the title and content of Section III of the Special Part of the Criminal Code of Ukraine, where criminal offences do not always reflect honour and dignity as direct objects of criminal liability. This discussion provides the basis for recommendations for improving the legislation based on the needs of modern society and international human rights standards. The terms “will” and “freedom”, their meaning and application in criminal law are separately considered, including proposals to replace the concept of “will” with “freedom” to ensure a more accurate reflection of legislative intentions.
The objective aspect of such offences, including illegal deprivation of liberty, abduction, enforced disappearance, child substitution and exploitation, is examined. The authors examine how these acts are qualified depending on the method, consequences and specifics of the restriction of freedom, honour or dignity. Particular attention is paid to the subjective side, which includes the direct intent of the perpetrator and the motives that affect the nature of the offence.
In conclusion, the author notes that criminal law protection of freedom, honour and dignity of a person requires not only improvement of legislation, but also ensuring its compliance with international standards. The author suggests ways to improve the effectiveness of law enforcement by clarifying the qualifying features and improving legal mechanisms.
1. Politova, A. S. (2007). Criminal Law Characteristics of Crimes Against the Freedom of the Person under the Legislation of Ukraine: PhD thesis: 12.00.08. Kyiv, 20 p. [In Ukrainian].
2. Volodina, O. O. (2003). Criminal liability for kidnapping (analysis of the elements of the crime): PhD thesis: 12.00.08. Kharkiv, 229 p. [In Ukrainian].
3. Khramtsov, O. M. (2015). Criminal law and criminological provision of protection of a person from violence: a monograph. Kharkiv: NikaNova, 472 p. [In Ukrainian].
4. Criminal Code of Ukraine of 05.04.2001 No. 2341-III. Baza danyh “Zakonodavstvo Ukrainy” / VR Ukrainy. 2001, No. 25–26, 131 p. [In Ukrainian].
5. Big Explanatory Dictionary of the Modern Ukrainian Language (with additions and supplements) (2005) / compiled and edited by V. T. Busel. Kyiv; Irpin: Perun, 1728 p. [In Ukrainian].
6. Decision of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine in the case on the constitutional petition of the Ukrainian Parliament Commissioner for Human Rights on the compliance of the third sentence of part one of Article 13 of the Law of Ukraine “On Mental Health Care” with the Constitution of Ukraine (case on judicial control over the hospitalisation of incapacitated persons in a psychiatric institution) of 1 June 2016. No. 2-rp/2016. Retrieved from: http://zakon3.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/v002p710-16 (Аccessed 20.01.2025). [In Ukrainian].
7. Scientific and Practical Commentary on the Criminal Code of Ukraine. (2019). Edited by O. M. Litvinov. Kyiv: Centre for Educational Literature, 528 p. [In Ukrainian].
8. Korzhansky, M. Y. (2001). Criminal Law and Legislation of Ukraine. General part. Course of lectures. Kyiv: Atika, 432 p. [In Ukrainian].
9. Qualification of crimes under investigation by internal affairs bodies: a textbook (2011) / edited by V.V. Kovalenko; under the scientific editorship of O. M. Dzhuzha and A. V. Savchenko. Kyiv: Atika, 648 p. [In Ukrainian].
10. Human Rights: Social and Anthropological Dimension (2060). Collective monograph. Works of the Lviv Laboratory of Human and Civil Rights of the Research Institute of State Building and Local Self-Government of the Academy of Legal Sciences of Ukraine / edited by P. M. Rabinovych (head editor) and others. Series I. Studies and abstracts. Issue 13. Lviv: Svit, 280 p. [In Ukrainian].
11. Scientific and Practical Commentary on the Criminal Code of Ukraine (2018) / edited by M. I. Melnyk, M.I. Khavroniuk. Kyiv: Dakor Publishing House, 1368 p. [In Ukrainian].
12. Shevchuk, S. (2018). Human dignity in the system of constitutional values. Law of Ukraine. No. 9.
P. 29–40. [In Ukrainian].
13. Scientific and Practical Commentary to the Criminal Code of Ukraine (2001). Special part. Comments to Articles 109-447 of the Criminal Code / edited by M. O. Potebenko, V. G. Goncharenko. Kyiv: Forum, 942 p. [In Ukrainian].
14. Hryshchuk, O. (2018). Philosophy of human dignity in law. Law of Ukraine. No. 9. P. 14–28. [In Ukrainian].
15. Hryshchuk, V. (2018). Social conditionality of criminal law protection and protection of human dignity in Ukraine. Law of Ukraine. No. 9. P. 98–108. [In Ukrainian].
16. Pidhorodynskyi, V. M. (2020). Crimes against the honour and dignity of a person (theoretical comparative legal study): Doctoral dissertation: 12.00.08. Odesa, 400 p. [In Ukrainian].
17. Jun, V. V. (2015). Sociology of constitutional law: a monograph. Book 1: Theoretical and methodological foundations. Kyiv: In Yure, 384 p. [In Ukrainian].
18. Holovaty, S. (2016). On human rights. Lectures. Kyiv: Dukh i Litera, i-xxiv + 760 pp. [In Ukrainian].
19. Qualification of crimes under investigation by internal affairs bodies: a textbook (2011) / edited by V.V. Kovalenko; under the scientific editorship of O. M. Dzhuzha and A. V. Savchenko. Kyiv: Atika, 648 p. [In Ukrainian].
20. Cárdenas, C. M. (2017). La desaparición forzada de personas en el Derecho Internacional de los Derechos Humanos: estudio de su evolución, concepto y reparación a las víctimas: tesis doctoral. Madrid: Universidad complutense de Madrid, xxx+601 p. [Іn English].
21. Ziero, G. W. (2015). The crime of enforced disappearance under the Rome Statute: the possibility for Prosecution of the crimes committed during the Brazilian Dictatorship. Sistema Penal & Violência. Vol. 7. No. 1. P. 162–177. [In English].
22. Criminal law (Special Part): textbook (2013) / edited by O. O. Dudorov, E. O. Pysmenskyi. Kyiv: Dakor Publishing House, 786 p. [In Ukrainian].
23. Davydovych, I., Onopenko, V. (2011). Hostage-taking: problems of determining the content of the objective side and correlation with other encroachments. Entrepreneurship, economy and law. No. 6 (186). Р. 127–130. [In Ukrainian].
24. Scientific and Practical Commentary on the Criminal Code of Ukraine (2016) / D. S. Azarov, V. K. Hryshchuk, A. V. Savchenko and others; edited by O. M. Dzhuzha, A. V. Savchenko, V. V. Cherney. Kyiv: Yurinkom Inter, 1064 p. [In Ukrainian].
25. Chiger, V. Criminal liability for human trafficking (2019). Entrepreneurship, economy and law. No. 5. P. 266–269. [In Ukrainian].
26. Orleans, A. M. (2014). Criminal law provision in Ukraine for the protection of human beings from exploitation: a monograph. Kamianets-Podilskyi: Buynitskyi O. A., 456 p. [In Ukrainian].
27. Kalmykov, D. O. Criminal liability for the exploitation of children: a monograph (2012) / scientific editor Doctor of Law, professor M. I. Khavroniuk. Luhansk: Luhansk State University of Internal Affairs named after E. O. Didorenko, 560 p. [In Ukrainian].
28. Akimov, M. O. (2009). Criminal Law Characteristics of Hostage Taking under the Legislation of Ukraine: PhD thesis: 12.00.08. Kyiv, 16 p. [In Ukrainian].
29. Krivokon, D. A. (2018). Human trafficking: criminal law analysis. Young scientist. No. 10 (62). С. 667–670. [In Ukrainian].
30. Topuzian, A. R. (2018). Criminal Law Protection of Morality of Minors in Ukraine: PhD thesis: 12.00.08. Kharkiv, 249 p. [In Ukrainian].
31. Andrushko, A. V. (2020). Theoretical and applied principles of preventing and combating crimes against the will, honour and dignity of a person: a monograph. Kyiv: Vaite, 560 p. [In Ukrainian].
32. Datsenko, E. V. (2015). Criminal and legal characteristics of child substitution: PhD thesis: 12.00.08. Kyiv, 20 p. [In Ukrainian].
33. Council of Europe Convention on Action against Trafficking in Human Beings of 16 May 2005: Retrieved from: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/994_858#Text (Аccessed 21.01.2025). [In Ukrainian].
34. Criminal Law of Ukraine: Special Part: Textbook (2015) / edited by Prof. V. Y. Tatsiy, V. I. Borisov, V. I. Tiutiugin. Kharkiv: Pravo, 680 p. [In Ukrainian].
35. The verdict of the Bolhrad District Court of Odesa Region of 25 March 2016 (case No. 497/352/16-к) / Unified State Register of Court Decisions. Retrieved from: http://reyestr.court.gov.ua/Review/57189623 (Аccessed 21.01.2025). [In Ukrainian].
36. Criminal Code of Ukraine. Scientific and practical commentary: in 2 volumes (2013) / edited by V. Y. Tatsiy, V. P. Pshonka, V. I. Borisov, V. I. Tiutiugin. Vol. 2: Special part / Yu. Baulin, V. I. Borisov, V. I. Tyutyugin et al. Kharkiv: Pravo, 1040 p. [In Ukrainian].
37. Dudorov, O. O., Khavroniuk, M. I. (2014). Criminal law: a textbook / edited by M. I. Khavroniuk. Kyiv: Vaite, 944 p. [In Ukrainian].
38. Scientific and Practical Commentary to the Criminal Code of Ukraine (2005) / edited by S. S. Yatsenko. Kyiv: A. S. K., 848 p. [In Ukrainian].
39. Scientific and Practical Commentary to the Criminal Code of Ukraine: in 2 volumes. Vol. 1 (2009) / edited by P. P. Andrushko, V. G. Honcharenko, Y. V. Fesenko. Kyiv: Alerta; KNT; Centre for Educational Literature, 964 p.
[In Ukrainian].
40. Lyzogub, Y. (2012). Qualifying signs of illegal deprivation of human liberty: scientific arguments against legislative facts. Entrepreneurship, economy and law. No. 7. P. 91–94 [In Ukrainian].
41. The verdict of the Oleksandriya City District Court of Kirovohrad Oblast of 14 May 2014 (case No. 398/7920/13-к) / Unified State Register of Court Decisions. Retrieved from: http://reyestr.court.gov.ua/Review/38748209 date of (Аccess: 21.01.2025). [In Ukrainian].
42. The verdict of the Synelnykivskyi City District Court of Dnipropetrovska oblast of 9 November 2012 (case No. 437/2531/12) / Unified State Register of Court Decisions. Retrieved from: http://reyestr.court.gov.ua/Review/27878794 date of access: 21.01.2025 [In Ukrainian].
43. Lemekha, R. I. (2017). Grave consequences as a cross-cutting criminal law concept: monograph / edited by V. O. Navrotskyi. Lviv: Rastr-7 Publishing House, 180 p. [In Ukrainian].
44. Andrushko, A. V. (2018). Problems of qualification of hostage taking. Journal of Kyiv University of Law. No. 3. P. 231–235 [In Ukrainian].