JOURNALISM IMPARTIALITY: HOW TO WRITE ABOUT RELIGIOUS COMMUNITIES

2024;
: 44-52
1
Odesa I. Mechnykov National University
2
Odesa I. Mechnykov National University

Existing journalistic standards are designed to prevent conflicts within society. In particular, this concerns the standard of balance of opinions, points of view, which implies the need to «give the floor to all parties to the conflict and reflect their positions, while the journalist himself must be as impartial as possible». Specifying of this standard, experts advise to avoid a false balance to consult with professional experts and to refuse altogether from writing material in case of lack of information. The standard of separation of facts from comments is also designed to convey the most unbiased information, where the position of the journalist himself, if any, is presented separately from the information presented.

However, the journalist is a part of this culture of perception of the world that exists in this society. the consequence of the above is, in our opinion, that the journalist is not aware of the presence of his own prejudices, and therefore it is quite difficult for him to avoid them.

Prejudice against Protestant religious communities has deep historical roots. Thus, in the Russian Empire, Protestants were forbidden to carry out missionary activities in relation to the Orthodox population. Both in imperial times and in Soviet times, the «struggle against sects» was relevant, which usually meant any deviations from the dominant religion/ideology. The Soviet authorities added to this active anti-religious propaganda with the help of cinematography. A vivid example of such propaganda is, in particular, the tape «Clouds over Borsk», where Pentecostal Protestants are presented as a group that makes human sacrifices.

Conducted field studies prove the stability of such ideas. Thus, among the Orthodox, there is a widespread opinion about the «exorcism» of Pentecostals, not knowing the denominational affiliation of Protestants («probably not Christians») and even ideas about human sacrifices.

The questions raised in this investigation relate, firstly, to the presence/absence of extrapolation of similar ideas to individual journalistic materials devoted to sensitive religious topics. Secondly, we are trying to find out in what way it is possible to create unbiased journalistic material on religious topics. For this purpose, an analysis of the material for compliance with journalistic standards and an interview with the journalist – the author of the material, were conducted.

  1. Schöpflin George, Geoffrey, A. (Ed.). (1997). «The Functions of Myth and a Taxonomy of Myths». In Myths and Nationhood. P. 19-36. 
  2. Tkhorzhevska, T. V. (2021). Obraz «chuzhoho» v radianskomu kinematohrafi ta (post)radianska identychnist [The Image of the «Alien» in Soviet Cinema and (Post)Soviet Identity]. Narodoznavchi zoshyty [Ethnographic Notebooks], 6 (162), 1435-1440.https://doi.org/10.15407/nz2021.06.1435 
  3. Kominko, Y. M. (2006). Relihiina tematyka na storinkakh providnykh zahalnonatsionalnykh vydan [Religious topics on the pages of leading national publications]. Naukovi zapysky in-tu zhurnalistyky [Scientific Notes of the Institute of Journalism], 22, 69-74.
  4. Kominko, Y. M. (2006). Funktsionalno-stylistychni osoblyvosti publikatsiii na relihiyinu tematyku v suchasnii vitchyznianii presi [Functional and stylistic features of publications on religious topics in the modern domestic press]. Retrieved from http://journlib.univ.kiev.ua/index.php?act=article&article=1546.
  5. Sklenar, I. M. (2008). Spetsyfika roboty suchasnoho zhurnalistaz relihiinoiu informatsiieiu [Specifics of the work of modern journalists with religious information]. Retrieved from https://risu.org.ua/ua/index/projects/ masmedia/16012/
  6. Boyko, A. A. (2009). Relihiia v mas-media Ukrainy : Teksty lektsii [Religion in the mass media of Ukraine : Lecture notes]. Kyiv. 
  7. Boyko. A.A. (2013). Relihiia i polityka v media: osoblyvosti spryiniattia informatsii molodizhnoiu audytoriieiu [Religion and politics in the media: peculiarities of perception of information by the youth audience]. Zbirnyk prats Naukovo-doslidnoho instytutu presoznavstva [Collection of works of the Research Institute of Press Studies], 3, 307-319.
  8. Kozyupa, I., Kostenko, І., O. Kholod, О. (2011). Problematyka ZMI : navch. posib. [Media Issues: a textbook]. (in 2 vols.; Vol. 2). (O. Kholod, Ed. and compiled by). Kyiv: Kyiv International University. 
  9. Tkhorzhevska, T. V. (2021). Obraz «chuzhoho» v radianskomu kinematohrafi ta (post)radianska identychnist [The Image of the «Alien» in Soviet Cinema and (Post)Soviet Identity]. Narodoznavchi zoshyty [Ethnographic Notebooks], 6 (162), 1435-1440.https://doi.org/10.15407/nz2021.06.1435 
  10. Tkhorzhevska, T. V. (2011). Stereotypni uiavlennia pravoslavnykh pro «shtundu» [Stereotypical ideas of the Orthodox about «shtunda»]. Naukovyi shchorichnyk «Istoriia relihii v Ukraini». Instytut relihiieznavstva [Scientific yearbook «History of Religions in Ukraine». Institute of Religious Studies], Issue 21, Book 1, 657-665. 
  11. Tkhorzhevska, T. V. (2021). Obraz «chuzhoho» v radianskomu kinematohrafi ta (post)radianska identychnist [The Image of the «Alien» in Soviet Cinema and (Post)Soviet Identity]. Narodoznavchi zoshyty [Ethnographic Notebooks], 6 (162), 1435-1440.https://doi.org/10.15407/nz2021.06.1435 
  12. Kominko, Y. M. (2006). Funktsionalno-stylistychni osoblyvosti publikatsiii na relihiyinu tematyku v suchasnii vitchyznianii presi [Functional and stylistic features of publications on religious topics in the modern domestic press]. Retrieved from http://journlib.univ.kiev.ua/index.php?act=article&article=1546. 
  13. Panyo, T. (2002, June 27). Deux ex machina? [Deux ex machina?]. Dzerkalo Tyzhnia [Mirror of the week]. Retrieved from https://zn.ua/ukr/SOCIUM/deus_ex_machina.html.
  14. «Odessa: sviashchennik bez styda i sovesti obmanul veruiushchikh» [«Odesa: a priest without shame and conscience deceived the faithful»]. Retrieved from https://rupor.od.ua/news/Odessa-svyaschennik-bez-styda-i-sovestiobmanul-...
  15. Sklenar, I. M. (2008). Spetsyfika roboty suchasnoho zhurnalistaz relihiinoiu informatsiieiu [Specifics of the work of modern journalists with religious information]. Retrieved from https://risu.org.ua/ua/index/ projects/masmedia/16012/. 
  16. Filippova, O. (2020, December 17-19). Pid odnym nebesnym kupolom. Yak pochuvaiutsia mali relihiini hromady na Odeshchyni [Under one heavenly dome. How do small religious communities in Odesa region feel]. Chornomorski novyny [Black Sea News]. Retrieved from https://chornomorka.com/archive/22215-22216/a14672.html.