Control and supervision of the execution of judicial decisions by penitentiary institutions in Ukraine

Authors: 

K. Hnot

The article presents the content, classification and meaning of the control over the activities of penitentiary institutions, examines the problem of the relation of control and supervision, considers the specific features of procurator’s supervision over law compliance in penitentiary institutions in the execution of judicial decisions in criminal cases, highlighted the role of civil society institutions in penitentiary government action.

1. Tyun V. M. Spivvidnoshennya kontrolyu i nahlyadu pravookhoronnykh orhaniv u sferi okhorony pryrody [The correlation of the control and supervisionof law enforcement bodies in the sphere of nature protection]. Naukovyy visnyk Mizhnarodnoho humanitarnoho universytetu, 2013, Vol. 6–1, pp. 144–147. Available at: http://nbuv.gov.ua/UJRN/Nvmgu_jur_2013_6-1(2)__37 (accessed 16.01.2016). 2.Busel V.T. Velykyy tlumachnyy slovnyk suchasnoyi ukrayins'koyi movy [Big explanatory dictionary of modern Ukrainian language]. Kiev; Irpen: Perun Publ., 2004. 1440 p. 3. Korulya I. V. Derzhavnyy kontrol' ta nahlyad yak efektyvni zasoby diyal'nosti militsiyi u sferi protydiyi koruptsiyi [State control and supervision as effective means of police activitiesin combating corruption]. Naukovyy visnyk Uzhhorods'koho natsional'noho universytetu, 2014, Vol. 25, pp. 168–171. Available at: http://nbuv.gov.ua/ UJRN/nvuzhpr_2014_25_42(accessed 16.01.2016). 4. Bytyak Yu. P., Harashchuk V. M., Bohuts'kyy V. V. Za zah. red. Bytyaka Yu. P., Harashchuka V. M., Zuy V. V. Administratyvne pravo [Administrative law]. Kharkov: Pravo Publ., 2010. 624 p. 5. Hrytsayenko L. Derzhavnyy kontrol' i prokurors'kyy nahlyad: sutnist' ta spivvidnoshennya [State control and рrosecutor's supervision: the nature and correlation]. Visnyk Natsional'noyi akademiyi prokuratury Ukrayiny, 2012, Vol. 2, рр. 34–38. Available at: http://nbuv.gov.ua/ UJRN/ Vnapu_2012_2_8(accessed 16.01.2016). 6. Ostapenko O. I., Kisil' Z. R., Kovaliv M. V., Kisil' R. V. Administratyvne pravo [Administrative law]. Kiev: Vseukrayins'ka asotsiatsiya vydavtsiv “Pravova yednist'”, 2008. 536 р. 7. Sykal M. M. Kontrol' za diyal'nistyu Derzhavnoyi kryminal'no-vykonavchoyi sluzhby Ukrayiny: pravovi ta orhanizatsiyni zasady. Avtoref. dys ... kand. yuryd. nauk [Control over the activity ofthe State Penitentiary Service of Ukraine:legal and organizational principles]. Kiev, 2012. 19 р. 8. Dzhuzha O. M., Bohatyr'ov I. H., Kolb O. H., Vasylevych V. V. ta in. Za zah. red. dokt. yuryd. nauk, prof. Dzhuzhy O. M.Kryminal'no-vykonavche pravo Ukrayiny [Criminal- Executive law of Ukraine]. Kiev: Atika Publ., 2010. 752 p. 9. Yevropeys'ka konventsiya pro zapobihannya katuvannyam chy nelyuds'komu abo takomu, shcho prynyzhuye hidnist', povodzhennyu chy pokarannyu, pryynyata 26.11.1987 r. [European Convention for the prevention of torture or inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment from 26.11.1987]. Available at: zakon.rada.gov.ua (accessed 12.01.2016). 10. Yevropeys'ki penitentsiarni (v“yaznychni) pravyla, pryynyati 12.02.1987 r. [European prison rules from 12.02.1987]. Available at: zakon.rada.gov.ua (accessed 12.01.2016). 11. Verkhovna Rada Ukrayiny. Kryminal'no-vykonavchyy kodeks Ukrayiny, pryynyatyy 11.07.2003 r. № 1129-IV [Criminal-Executive code of Ukraine from 11.07.2003 № 1129-IV]. Available at: zakon.rada.gov.ua (accessed 02.01.2016). 12. Yedynak T. S., Pavlyshen O. V. Kontrol' yak funktsiya derzhavnoho upravlinnya: sutnist' ta klasyfikatsiya [Control as a function of governance: essence and classification]. Visnyk Akademiyi mytnoyi sluzhby Ukrayiny, 2011, Vol. 1, pp. 12–18. Available at: http://nbuv.gov.ua/UJRN/ vamcudu_2011_1_2(accessed 25.01.2016). 13. Verkhovna Rada Ukrayiny. Zakon Ukrayiny “Pro Upovnovazhenoho Verkhovnoyi Rady Ukrayiny z prav lyudyny”, pryynyatyy 23.12.1997 r. № 776/97-ВР [The Law of Ukraine “On the Commissioner of Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine on human rights” from 23.12.1997 № 776/97-ВР]. Available at: zakon.rada.gov.ua (accessed 12.01.2016). 14. Verkhovna Rada Ukrayiny. Zakon Ukrayiny “Pro Derzhavnu kryminal'no-vykonavchu sluzhbu Ukrayiny”, pryynyatyy 23.06.2005 r. № 2713-IV [The Law of Ukraine “On State Criminal-Executive service of Ukraine” from 23.06.2005 № 2713-IV]. Available at: zakon.rada.gov.ua (accessed 11.01.2016). 15. Kabinet Ministriv Ukrayiny. Postanova “Polozhennya pro Derzhavnu penitentsiarnu sluzhbu Ukrayiny”, pryynyata 02.07.2014 r. № 225 [Resolution “Regulation of the State Penitentiary Service of Ukraine” from 02.07.2014 № 225]. Available at: zakon.rada.gov.ua (accessed 04.01.2016). 16. Ministerstvo yustytsiyi Ukrayiny. Pravyla vnutrishn'oho rozporyadku ustanov vykonannya pokaran', zatverdzheni 29.12.2014 r. № 2186/5 [Internal regulations of penal institutions from 29.12.2014 № 2186/5]. Available at:
zakon.rada.gov.ua (accessed 27.01.2016). 17. Romanenko O. V. Penitentsiarna funktsiya demokratychnoyi pravovoyi derzhavy ta rol' hromadyans'koho suspil'stva v mekhanizmi yiyi realizatsiyi. Avtoref. dys ... kand. yuryd. nauk [Penitentiary function of a democratic law state and the role of civil society in the mechanism of its implementation]. Kiev, 2004. 21 р. Available at: i-rc.org.ua/files/personalii/romanenko-o-v.pdf (accessed 03.02.2016). 18. Anpilohov O. V., Kutyepov Yu. V., Yakovets' I. S., Avtukhov K. A. Za zah. red. Stepanyuka A. Kh. Zahal'ni zasady diyal'nosti sposterezhnykh komisiy [General principles of monitoring commissions]. Kharkov: Pravo Publ., 2014. 284 р. 19. Krasnolobov I., Yakovets' I. Aktual'ni pytannya orhanizatsiyi ta zdiysnennya hromads'koho kontrolyu za povedinkoyu osib, umovno-dostrokovo zvil'nenykh vid vidbuvannya pokarannya [Current issues of organization and implementation of public control over the behaviour of personsconditionallyahead of schedule released from punishment]. Visnyk Natsional'noyi akademiyi prokuratury Ukrayiny, 2010, Vol. 2, pp. 74–79. Available at: http://nbuv. gov.ua/UJRN/Vnapu_2010_2_15(accessed 27.01.2016). 20. Skrypnyuk O. Konstytutsiyno-pravovyy status prokuratury Ukrayiny: zavdannya, funktsiyi, povnovazhennya [Constitutional and legal status of Prosecutor's office of Ukraine: tasks, functions, powers]. Visnyk Natsional'noyi akademiyi prokuratury Ukrayiny, 2009, Vol. 2, pp. 21–27. Available at: http:// nbuv.gov.ua/UJRN/Vnapu_2009_2_6 (accessed 25.01.2016). 21. Kurylo M. P. Prokurors'kyy nahlyad za doderzhannyam prav ta zakonnykh interesiv zasudzhenykh do pozbavlennya voli. Avtoref. dys ... kand. yuryd. nauk [Prosecutor's supervision over observance of rights and legitimate interests of convicted persons to imprisonment]. Kharkov, 1998. 18 р. 22. Verkhovna Rada Ukrayiny. Zakon Ukrayiny “Pro prokuraturu”, pryynyatyy 14.10.2014 r. № 1697-VІІ [The Law of Ukraine “On the Prosecutor's office” from 14.10.2014 № 1697-VІІ]. Available at: zakon.rada.gov.ua (accessed 11.01.2016). 23. Heneral'na prokuratura Ukrayiny. Nakaz “Pro orhanizatsiyu diyal'nosti prokuroriv z nahlyadu za doderzhannyam zakoniv pry vykonanni sudovykh rishen' u kryminal'nykh spravakh, a takozh pry zastosuvanni inshykh zakhodiv prymusovoho kharakteru, pov“yazanykh z obmezhennyam osobystoyi svobody hromadyan” vid 20.04.2016 r. № 161 [Оrder “On the оrganization of activities of public prosecutors on supervision over the observance of laws at execution of court decisions in criminal cases,and when other coercive measures related with the restriction of personal freedom of citizens” from 20.04.2016 №161]. Available at: www.gp.gov.ua/(accessed 22.04.2016).