Judicial bodies as subjects of the system of administrative and legal guarantee of the activities of religious organizations in Ukraine

Victoriya CHORNOPYSKA "Judicial bodies as subjects of the system of administrative and legal guarantee of the activities of religious organizations in Ukraine".

https://science.lpnu.ua/law/all-volumes-and-issues/volume-11-number-1-41...

1
Lviv Polytechnic National University, Institute of Jurisprudence and Psychology

The article characterizes the peculiarities of the functioning of judicial bodies as subjects of the system of administrative and legal guarantee of the activity of religious organizations in Ukraine. Implementation by judicial bodies of administrative and legal guarantees of the activities of religious organizations is carried out by the system of courts of general jurisdiction, administrative courts, and the Supreme Court of Ukraine, acting on the same basis, regarding the implementation of joint tasks in the sphere of justice. It was noted that judicial bodies are the subjects of guaranteeing the right to legalize the legal status of a religious organization, protection of their property and other rights. Of particular importance in this area is the activity of judicial bodies regarding the recognition of decisions, actions, inaction of public administration bodies regarding religious organizations as being contrary to the law, bringing persons guilty of offenses regarding religious organizations to administrative responsibility, etc.

The specific features of judicial bodies regarding the administrative-legal guarantee of the functioning of religious organizations are determined: 1) the possibility of implementation by judicial bodies of administrative-legal guarantees of the activity of religious organizations endowed with state support, which is caused by the assignment of these bodies to one of the branches of government in Ukraine on the basis of Art. 6 of the Constitution of Ukraine, 2) extending the jurisdiction of courts to all types of legal relations in the religious sphere existing in the state;   3) the activity of judicial bodies acts as a condition for guaranteeing the legal possibilities of religious organizations regarding the judicial consideration of the case and the implementation of judicial protection of their rights; 4) they are the subjects of guaranteeing the right to legalization of the legal status of a religious organization, protection of their property and other rights, safety of peaceful activities by them, protection of the rights of these institutions from violations by subjects of authority under the procedure of the Criminal Code of Ukraine, punishment in the administrative order for activities that have an illegal destructive effect on the functioning of religious organizations, etc.

1. Barannik R. V. (2011) Sudovi, pravookhoronni ta pravozakhysni orhany Ukrainy [Judicial, law enforcement and human rights bodies of Ukraine]. Kyiv: KNT Publ. 352 p. [in Ukrainian].

2. Shumskyi P. V. (2000) Sudovi i pravookhoronni orhany Ukrainy [Judicial and law enforcement bodies of Ukraine]. Ternopil, LILEIa Publ. 186 p. [in Ukrainian].

3. Bilozorov Ye. V. (2009) Pravovi harantii prav i svobod liudyny ta hromadianyna u sferi diialnosti militsii [Legal guarantees of human and citizen rights and freedoms in the field of police activity]. Kyiv: Avanpost-prym Publ. 189 p. [in Ukrainian].

4. Stakhura B. I. (2016) Rol orhaniv derzhavnoi vlady u zabezpechenni prav liudyny i hromadianyna v demokratychnomu suspilstvi: teoretyko-pravovyi vymir [The role of state authorities in ensuring human and citizen rights in a democratic society: theoretical and legal dimension]: avtoref. dys. ...kand. yuryd. nauk: 12.00.01. Lvivskyi derzhavnyi universytet vnutrishnikh sprav. Lviv. 16 p. [in Ukrainian].

5. Vovk D. O. (2014) Yak ukrainski sudy balansuiut relihiinu svobodu: analiz u konteksti svitskosti [How Ukrainian courts balance religious freedom: an analysis in the context of secularism]. Pravo i hromadianske suspilstvo. No 3. P. 4–37. [in Ukrainian].

6.           Rishennia Mykolaivskoho okruzhnoho administratyvnoho sudu 07 travnia 2019 r. № 400/405/19 m. Mykolaiv «Pro vyznannia protypravnoiu bezdiialnist ta zobov`iazannia vchynyty pevni dii» [Decision of the Mykolaiv District Administrative Court of May 7, 2019 No. 400/405/19 of Mykolaiv "On recognition of illegal inaction and obligation to perform certain actions."]. URL: https://reyestr.court.gov.ua/Review/81694906 (Accessed: 22.02.2024). [in Ukrainian].

7.           Rzhepetska K. M. (2009) Sudovyi kontrol yak administratyvno-pravovyi zasib zakhystu prav i svobod liudyny [Judicial control as an administrative and legal means of protection of human rights and freedoms]. Forum prava. No 2. P. 364–368. [in Ukrainian].

8. Kodeks administratyvnoho sudochynstva Ukrainy [Administrative Judicial Code of Ukraine]. Baza danykh «Zakonodavstvo Ukrainy» / VR Ukrainy. URL: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/ show/2747-15#Text. (Accessed:: 22.02.2024). [in Ukrainian].

9. Rishennia Okruzhnoho administratyvnoho sudu m. Kyieva vid  31 sichnia 2019 roku № 826/12479/18 «Pro vyznannia protypravnymy dii Kyivskoi miskoi derzhavnoi administratsii» [Decision of the District Administrative Court of Kyiv dated January 31, 2019 No. 826/12479/18 "On recognizing illegal actions of the Kyiv City State Administration"]. URL: https://youcontrol.com.ua/catalog/court-document/79633487/ (Accessed: 22.02.2024). [in Ukrainian].

10.          Postanova Lvivskoho okruzhnoho administratyvnoho sudu za pozovom chlena hreko-katolytskoi hromady s. Dmytriv Radekhivskoho raionu do Departamentu z pytan kultury, natsionalnostei ta relihii LODA, Lvivskoi oblasnoi derzhavnoi administratsii  vid 10 zhovtnia 2016 roku  u spravi № 813/1368/16 [The decision of the Lviv District Administrative Court on the claim of a member of the Greek-Catholic community of Dmytriv of Radekhiv district to the Department of Culture, Nationalities and Religions of the Lviv Regional State Administration of Lviv Regional State Administration dated October 10, 2016 in case No. 813/1368/16]. URL:  https://reyestr.court.gov.ua/Review/62030441# (Accessed: 22.02.2024). [in Ukrainian].

11.          Postanova Okruzhnyi administratyvnyi sud m. Kyieva vid 03 veresnia 2014 roku. Sprava №826/11217/14 [Resolution of the District Administrative Court of Kyiv dated September 3, 2014. Case No. 826/11217/14]. URL: https://reyestr.court.gov.ua/Review/40428552 (Accessed: 22.02.2024). [in Ukrainian].

12.          Zakon Ukrainy «Pro sudoustrii i status suddiv» [The Law of Ukraine "On the Judiciary and the Status of Judges"]. Baza danykh «Zakonodavstvo Ukrainy» / VR Ukrainy. (Accessed: 22.02.2024). [in Ukrainian].

13.          Postanova Dzerzhynskoho miskoho sudu Donetskoi oblasti 24 sichnia 2014 roku «Pro prytiahnennia do administratyvnoi vidpovidalnosti za ch.1 st. 51KUpAP». Sprava № 3/225/79/2014 [Resolution of the Dzerzhyn city court of the Donetsk region on January 24, 2014 "On bringing to administrative responsibility under Part 1 of Art. 51 KUPAP". Case No. 3/225/79/2014]. URL: https://reyestr.court.gov.ua/Review/49129303 (Accessed: 22.02.2024). [in Ukrainian].