Religion and Law as Value-Normative Institutions in Modern Society

Kelman, M. (2025). Religion and Law as Value-Normative Institutions in Modern Society. Veritas: Legal and Psychological-Pedagogical Research. 1(2), 32–41. DOI:

Authors:
1
Lviv Polytechnic National University, Educatinoal and Rasearch Institute for Law, Psychology and Innovative Education

Abstract. Throughout its historical existence, humanity has sought to comprehend, understand, and
become aware of itself, the surrounding world, its place within the world, and the world within itself. In this
respect, the realms of religion and law are no exception. Since ancient times, humanity has been interested in
the nature and essence of human relations, as well as the norms and rules that define their characteristics. The
object of human understanding has consistently been the relationships between religious and legal phenomena,
their ontological foundations, and their values and significance in individual and societal life. Religion and law
play a significant role in the lives of individuals and communities. They provide a sense of meaning and
purpose in difficult times and help people navigate complex ethical and moral issues. Religion and law have
played a significant role in shaping human history and culture, influencing art, literature, music and philosophy,
and contributing to the development of social and political institutions. However, the relationship between
religion and law is complex and multifaceted.

In addition, not everyone finds religion relevant or important to their lives, and there are many different
beliefs and perspectives on the role and meaning of religion. Ultimately, the role of religion depends on
individual beliefs, values and experiences and can vary across cultures, societies and historical periods.
Nevertheless, for many people, religion can offer a source of meaning, community, guidance and support that
enriches their lives and helps them navigate the complexities of the world.

There are almost no attempts to theorize the relationship between religion and law in scholarly works.
The forms of influence of religion on lawmaking and law enforcement remain outside the attention of legal
scholars. Existing research in this area is often characterized by fragmentation.

Modern jurisprudence contains little information about the interaction of religious norms and law in
regulating social relations. Under such conditions, there is an urgent need for a scientific analysis of this issue.

The purpose of this research is to establish, on the basis of modern legal understanding, the basic
principles of the relationship between religion and law, and to clarify the role of religion in the legal plane.

Today, the church and religious organizations play a significant role in the life of Ukrainian society, making
every effort to solve certain problems. This became especially evident during Russia’s large-scale treacherous
invasion of Ukraine and the Russian-Ukrainian war.

The issues of the relationship between religion and law have been the subject of consideration by many
scholars, including A. Baumeister, V. Blikhar, O. Vovk, O. Danilian, R. Dvorkin, E. Yevgrafova, and others.

The philosophical and methodological foundation of the study is based on the principle of pluralism in
the selection of methodological approaches, methods, and techniques, as these form the basis of the scientific
and cognitive process. This principle ensures unity and purposefulness in the examination of the shared features
of religion and law in law-making and law enforcement, such as ritual, tradition, authority, and universality.

It is argued that in modern society, although religious values are losing their former meaning of the
“sacred image” of the world, and even if Christian principles do not have a direct impact on the legal system,
they still play a significant role in legal life, because European legal culture was created under the influence of
Christianity and the Christian view of the world. Modern European legal systems operate in a social system that
has absorbed Christian religious values.

The research is aimed at further developing the general theory and philosophy of law, deepening
knowledge about the relationship between religion and law in the system of social regulation, and improving
legislation. The results obtained can be used in law-making and law enforcement practice, in the preparation of
textbooks, manuals, for lawyers, philosophers, sociologists and all those who are not indifferent to the
development of legal consciousness.

  1. Yermakova, G. S. (2016). The religious factor and its influence on the consolidation of human rights and freedoms in the legal field of the European Union. Scientific Bulletin of the International Humanities University. Series: Jurisprudence, 22, 19–23. 
  2. Lvova, O. L. (2007). Functional interaction of law and religion in the aspect of realization of human rights and freedoms. In N. M. Onishchenko & O. V. Zaychuk (Eds.), Problems of realization of human and civil rights and freedoms in Ukraine (pp. 313–320). Kyiv: Yurydychna Dymka. 
  3. Paida, Yu. Yu. (2012). The role of law and religion in the improvement of the mechanism of realization of human rights. Legal Bulletin “Air and Space Law”, 1, 65–70.
  4. Arabadzhi, N. (2021). The influence of Christianity on the legal system of Ukraine in the transformation of state and religious relations. Public Law, 2(42), 130–136. 
  5. Kelman, M. S., & Stratonov, V. M. (2020). General theory of law. Kherson: OLDI-PLUS. 
  6. Lytsky, I. M. (2012). Implementation of moral, ethical and religious norms in the basic provisions of the Constitution of Ukraine. Scientific and Information Bulletin of the Ivano-Frankivsk University of Law named after King Danylo Halytsky, 6, 17–22.
  7. Gutiv, B. I. (2021). Formation and functioning of state institutions and the law of the Vatican. Lviv: HALYCH-PRESS. 
  8. Vovk, D. O. (2008). Law and religion (Doctoral dissertation, Yaroslav Mudryi National Law University, Kharkiv, Ukraine). 
  9. The Bible, or the Book of Scripture of the Old and New Testaments. (1993). Kyiv: Ukrainian Bible Society. 
  10. Oborotov, Y. M. (2003). Church law in the domestic legal tradition. Odesa: Jurydychna literatura. Golfner, J. (2002). Cardinal. Christian social teaching. Lviv: Svichado. 
  11. Fuller, L. L. (1999). Anatomy of law. Kyiv: Sfera. 
  12. Pavlenko, O. (2011). Civilization. In Yu. Levenets & Yu. Shapoval (Eds.), Political Encyclopedia (p. 770). Kyiv: Parliamentary Publishing House. 
  13. Samokhvalov, V. V. (2000). Legality and justice in antiquity and the Middle Ages. Constitutional State, 11, 510–519. 
  14. Cicero, M. T. (2020). About laws. About the state. About the nature of the gods. Lviv: Apriori. 
  15. Voloshchenko, O. M. (2006). Canon law as a separate system of law. Journal of Kyiv University of Law, 2, 52–56. 
  16. Kelman, M., Nesprava, M., Tokarska, A., Vovk, V., & Skrypa, Ye. (2020). Ontology of good and evil in the understanding of the great Christian teachers and saints. Journal of Legal, Ethical and Regulatory Issues, 23(5). Retrieved from: https://www.abacademies.org/articles/ontology-of-good-and-evil-in-the-understanding-of-great-christian-teachers-and-saints-9668.html
  17. Kelman, M., Kristinyak, M., Andrusiak, I., Panchenko, S., & Kelman, R. (2021). The influence of the ruling elite on political activity in the conditions of destructuring the essence of the philosophy of law. WISDOM, 1(1), 91–97. https://doi.org/10.24234/wisdom.v1i1.603 
  18. Kalinin, Y. A., & Kharkovshchenko, E. A. (1994). Religious studies. Kyiv: Naukova Dumka. [In Ukraine]
  19. The Holy Scriptures. (2021). Lviv: Svichado. 
  20. Rechytsky, V. V. (2007). Symbolic reality and law. Lviv: VNTL-Classics.